The lumber industry is bracing for potential changes as talks about reintroducing Canadian softwood lumber tariffs resurface after the 2024 U.S. elections. President-Elect Donald Trump, known for his aggressive trade policies, has hinted at bringing back tariffs since his re-election. With decades of agreements and adaptations already in place, these tariffs are unlikely to make a major dent in the lumber market’s operations, and here is why.
What are softwood lumber agreements?
Softwood lumber agreements (SLAs) are trade deals between the U.S. and Canada designed to regulate the flow of Canadian lumber into the U.S. market. These agreements aim to avoid trade disputes and ensure a level playing field for U.S. producers. Essentially, they set rules around how much lumber Canada can export and at what cost, often using quotas, taxes, or both.
The first major agreement dates back to the 1980s when U.S. lumber producers complained that Canadian timber was unfairly subsidized, making it cheaper to sell. Since then, multiple agreements have been signed, one of the most notable being the 1996 SLA. This deal introduced export fees and volume limits on Canadian lumber to address U.S. concerns and reduce tensions between the two countries.
Over the years, these agreements have been renegotiated and adjusted to address changing trade dynamics. Still, their goal has always been the same: maintaining stability in the lumber market while managing competition between Canadian and American producers.
Current export charges under SLAs
Under past SLAs, Canadian exporters had to pay export charges when the market price of lumber fell below a certain point. For example, if the price dropped to US$355 or less per thousand board feet, charges ranged from 5% to 15%, depending on the exact cost and the option chosen by the region.
However, the most recent SLA expired in 2015, and no new agreement has been implemented. Since then, the U.S. has simply applied tariffs on Canadian softwood lumber imports. As of August 2024, these tariffs increased from 8.05% to 14.54%.
Why the Trump tariffs are likely to make little difference in the lumber industry
Tariffs on Canadian softwood lumber might sound like they’d shake up the market, but the reality is far more nuanced. The industry has weathered tariffs before, and it’s built to adapt. For starters, lumber prices are influenced more by supply and demand than by tariffs. Factors like housing starts, natural disasters, and global trade shifts have a more significant impact on pricing than a 10-15% tariff hike.
Another reason tariffs don’t hit as hard is that the market has adjusted over time. U.S. producers have ramped up their capacity to meet demand, reducing reliance on Canadian imports. At the same time, Canadian exporters have diversified, sending more lumber to Europe and Asia, where tariffs don’t apply.
In many cases, the added cost of tariffs is absorbed at different points in the supply chain. Distributors, builders, and even consumers may share the burden, but the increase is often spread thin enough to avoid dramatic disruptions. This balance makes tariffs less of a game-changer than they might appear on paper.
What does this mean for construction and housing?
For construction and housing, tariffs on Canadian lumber increase material costs, but the overall impact is manageable relative to a project’s total cost. Builders and developers are accustomed to dealing with fluctuations in material prices, whether from tariffs or other market forces, so the industry has strategies to minimize disruptions.
The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) estimated that past tariff hikes increased the cost of constructing a single-family home by nearly $9,000. While this increase is notable, it represents a small fraction of the overall expense, especially in markets where new homes can cost hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of dollars.
The construction industry has also explored alternatives in response to higher lumber prices. Materials like engineered wood, steel, and even prefabricated components are being used more frequently, which helps to offset some of the reliance on traditional softwood lumber. This diversification reduces the long-term impact of tariffs on building projects.
Final thoughts
While tariffs on Canadian softwood lumber have grabbed headlines, their impact on the industry is more muted than many might expect. The lumber market is influenced more by broader economic trends, like high interest rates and labor shortages, than by tariffs. So, while tariffs might add a bit of cost, they’re just one piece of a much bigger puzzle.
Curious about how trade policies like tariffs actually impact your business or the housing market? Subscribe to our newsletter for insights, expert tips, and updates that keep you ahead of the game.
