Workers in some of America’s hottest climates face new federal rules that could change when and how they work in extreme heat. OSHA’s recent heat regulations aim to safeguard workers from heat-related illnesses by setting temperature thresholds that limit outdoor labor when it gets too hot. While these rules intend to protect health and well-being, they’ve sparked debate, particularly in regions where people have grown accustomed to intense summer temperatures.

Quick look

• New OSHA heat rules set mandatory standards for breaks, hydration, and cooling access to protect workers from heat-related illnesses, sparking debate in high-temperature regions.
• Employers face logistical challenges and increased costs as they adapt to compliance changes, such as building cooling stations, rescheduling shifts, and conducting heat safety training.
• Advocates argue these regulations are crucial for preventing heat-related injuries and deaths, particularly in high-risk industries like construction and agriculture.
• Critics say OSHA’s one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t consider state-specific practices, raising concerns of federal overreach and costs, especially with potential administrative changes ahead.

The rules set standards for mandatory breaks, easy access to water, and rest time when temperatures are high. However, some workers and employers in hotter areas feel these rules bring extra restrictions they may not need. OSHA believes the measures are vital for preventing heat exhaustion and saving lives. Still, the debate highlights the tricky balance between nationwide safety rules and the unique needs of different regions.

What OSHA’s heat rules mean for workers

OSHA’s new regulations introduce clear steps to keep workers safe in high heat. These rules mainly apply to jobs that are outdoors or in hot indoor spaces, aiming to lower the risk of heat-related health issues:

• Mandatory rest breaks: Workers must take regular breaks in shaded or cool areas to cool down.
• Unlimited access to water: Cool drinking water must be easy to obtain so workers can stay hydrated throughout the day.
• Work adjustments based on temperature: When the heat peaks, employers may need to shorten shifts or switch up tasks to reduce time in the heat.
• Heat illness prevention plan: Employers need a written plan to educate workers on recognizing and preventing heat stress, with training on early warning signs.

These rules are especially relevant for construction, agriculture, and landscaping, where workers are often outside for long hours. To meet these guidelines, employers might need to make adjustments, like changing schedules or adding cooling areas. While workers appreciate the extra protection, some employers and state-based institutions are taking heat for questioning whether these strict rules are really needed.

The impact on workers and employers: Safety vs. practicality

The new heat rules are changing daily routines for both workers and employers, especially in outdoor jobs. From regular breaks to shorter shifts during peak heat, these changes aim to protect workers—but they come with some challenges.

For workers, the rules mean more frequent breaks and guaranteed access to water and shaded areas. For employers, however, these requirements create logistical challenges that can add extra costs and affect project timelines:

• Setting up cooling stations: Building shaded or cooled rest areas on large job sites can be costly and time-consuming.
• Scheduling adjustments: Changing shifts around peak heat times might reduce productivity, which can be challenging for tight project schedules.
• Costs of compliance: Providing extra water, training on heat safety, and setting up cooling areas all add up, especially for smaller companies with tight budgets.

Some employers feel the rules are too much, especially in areas where hot weather is a daily reality. Many argue that their workers know how to handle the heat safely without these extra requirements. For OSHA and worker safety groups, the investment in compliance is worth it to protect lives and create safer work environments. This ongoing debate highlights the challenge of balancing safety and practical needs.

‘It’s about saving lives’

OSHA and worker safety groups see the new heat rules as a big step in protecting workers from the dangers of extreme heat. For OSHA, these rules aren’t just about avoiding discomfort—they’re about saving lives in jobs that can be tough and risky.

Advocates point out that as temperatures keep rising, heat-related illnesses and deaths have become more common. This is especially true in jobs like construction and agriculture, where workers are outdoors for long hours and do physical labor. Heat stress can lead to serious conditions like heat exhaustion and, in some cases, heatstroke. 

The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reports a small but growing number of worker deaths from heat each year, though experts believe this is likely an undercount. Public Citizen, a consumer advocacy group, estimates that each year in the U.S., heat causes around 2,000 worker deaths and 170,000 heat-related injuries. For example, OSHA released findings from an investigation into the death of a 41-year-old worker who collapsed and died while picking oranges in Florida. The agency identified two labor violations and stated that the death was preventable.

Adding heat safety rules brings the U.S. closer to international standards that require employers to protect workers from extreme temperatures. OSHA’s new regulations are a step toward ensuring that workers don’t have to risk their health to earn a living. Supporters believe these rules aren’t meant to disrupt long-standing practices but to build a culture of safety that prepares workers for extreme conditions.

‘It’s overkill’

On the flip side, many companies, especially those from hotter states, feel that OSHA’s new heat rules overreach their goals without accounting for state-level nuances. Many states already have their own heat safety rules, but OSHA’s new rules face more resistance because they’re stricter and apply more widely. This means it might be tough to get them in place. Since the rules are coming out near the end of President Biden’s first term, a change in administration could affect their future. Former President Donald Trump, for example, has said he would roll back OSHA’s regulations for private businesses, so these rules might not move forward when he returns to office.

A recent Supreme Court decision limits the power of federal agencies, like OSHA, to make and enforce rules. This ruling raises questions about whether OSHA can fully implement and enforce its new heat safety rules.

These new requirements could also mean extra costs and stiff penalties for non-compliance. California’s Department of Finance estimates that workplace heat safety regulations will impact businesses “in the neighborhood of billions of dollars.” 

Can cooler heads prevail?

The debate over OSHA’s heat rules often involves finding a balance between keeping workers safe and recognizing the reality of hot climates. While safety is a priority, many believe rules should be flexible enough to adapt to different needs and regional conditions.

Some companies have already started using creative solutions to meet safety needs while keeping work moving. For example, certain construction companies in the Southeast and Southwest have shifted schedules to start earlier in the morning and avoid the worst afternoon heat. Others have invested in cooling vests or portable misting fans that help workers cool down without needing to stop as often. While these add upfront costs, they’re seen as practical alternatives to the strict OSHA requirements.

There’s also room to discuss adjustments to the rules. For instance, OSHA could consider “feels like” temperatures that account for humidity instead of a strict temperature cutoff. Regions with consistently high temperatures might also benefit from guidelines that consider local climate.

Looking ahead: What’s next?

OSHA’s new heat regulations are part of a larger shift to keep workers safe in a warming world. Supporters see the regulations as vital for reducing heat-related illnesses and building a safer work environment.

As OSHA continues to evaluate the impact of these rules, discussions about possible changes or region-specific adjustments are likely. With extreme weather becoming more common, these debates will shape the future of workplace safety, aiming to protect health while balancing the practical needs of different industries.

Like this and want more? Follow us on social media and subscribe to our weekly newsletter to stay tuned into the latest industry safety regulations and more.