HS2 Ltd has launched a formal investigation into serious allegations that labor suppliers on the UK high-speed rail project may have overcharged the taxpayer by misclassifying self-employed workers as salaried staff. The inquiry follows reports that contractors, including the well-known Danny Sullivan Group, were billing HS2 at full PAYE rates for workers who were actually self-employed.
Image courtesy of https://www.hs2.org.uk/
This issue is concerning because paye workers come with additional costs that include pensions, holiday pay, and national insurance, making them significantly more expensive to hire. If those costs were billed but not paid out to the workers, labor suppliers may have pocketed the difference. Multiple sources suggest the scale of the overcharging could run into the millions.
HS2 Ltd said it became aware of the issue earlier this year and suspended several staff members involved with approving payments. The company has now escalated the matter and appointed an external auditor to review all relevant labor supply contracts.
The Danny Sullivan Group confirmed it was cooperating with HS2 Ltd and had launched its own internal review. It stated that any discrepancies were unintentional, though questions remain about how long the practice had gone on and who at HS2 was responsible for verifying labor classification.
The Department for Transport (DfT), which oversees HS2 Ltd, has said it expects “full transparency” and warned that contractors found to be misusing public funds could be removed from the UK high speed rail project entirely. A spokesperson noted that the DfT is in close contact with HS2 Ltd and will review the audit findings.
This incident adds to the long list of issues surrounding the controversial high speed rail in UK, which has already seen ballooning budgets and the cancellation of major sections. Public confidence in the project was shaky to begin with and revelations of billing fraud are unlikely to help.
Lawmakers have also stepped in, with several MPs calling for a broader probe into labor practices on major public infrastructure projects. Some have asked whether this misclassification is common industry practice and whether enough checks are in place to catch it.
What does this mean for trade workers and trust?
For workers in construction and rail, the story hits close to home. Many self-employed tradespeople rely on accurate classification for their taxes and income reporting. When labor suppliers list them as salaried without their knowledge, it can lead to tax headaches and lost benefits down the line.
There’s also a more significant issue at play: accountability. HS2 Ltd is already under pressure to deliver a high-profile project within a heavily scrutinized budget. If supplier costs are being inflated through shady billing, the reputation of the entire enterprise takes a hit.
As HS2 continues its audit and suppliers brace for the findings, workers across the UK will be watching closely. So will taxpayers, who’ve already poured billions into a project now shadowed by doubts about how the money is being spent.
If you’re in the AEC and want to stay informed about the projects shaping our industry, sign up for our newsletter at https://underthehardhat.org/join-us.
